I'll tell you what it is. The music is catchy, the costumes are awesome, the actors are amazing and have fantastic voices, the choreography is breathtaking. Then of course the story has to be riveting and entertaining, and the songs must be entwined seamlessly into it. The songs have to help move the story along and/or express how the characters are feeling. They cannot be randomly thrown in just because.
So I have come up with my top 5 favorite musicals (excluding Disney):
5) Singin' In the Rain
I love this movie!
The story centers around a silent movie star, Don Lockwood, as his film studio makes the transition from silent movies into "talkies".
I enjoy the comedy, witty writing, and particularly Don's ditzy and screechy costar, Lina Lamont. The tap dancing in this film is phenomenal, nigh on hypnotizing. I think the musical numbers are more focused on showing off the footwork and less on the songs themselves (not necessarily a bad thing). There is a dance number included with literally every single song. The sets and costumes are amazing and all the actors have incredible voices. The reason I put it so low on my list is because most of the songs are a bit random. There's an entire sequence about ten minutes long where you're just sitting there watching like, "what on earth is happening?". If you've seen the movie, you'll know exactly what I'm talking about. It's such a tangent from the rest of the film and has no relevance whatsoever. There's a couple songs and scenes like that, where if you simply cut them, you would never notice.
Other than that, I adore the movie. Even with the strange, random song sequences, I love it (and I think those songs just adds to its charm). "What a glorious feeling I'm having again!"
"Moses Supposes"
4) Into the Woods
I've only recently become acquainted with this one. I had heard about it and listened to some of the music, but I had never actually seen it until a few months back… And I loved it!
It's a sort of mashup of many of the classic fairytales (Cinderella, Jack and the Beanstalk, Little Red Riding Hood, Rapunzel) as they journey into the woods for different purposes, crossing paths along the way. There's also a baker and his wife attempting to create a spell for a witch which requires ingredients from each of these characters.
I really enjoy the entwining of the fairytales. Even with the unexpected turn it takes halfway through the play, it still manages to be entertaining. The story is one of those "after happily ever after" stories, which people do not always enjoy. For some people, it might take some getting used to, but I really appreciate what was done. The comedy, when there is some, is hilarious (for it is a mostly serious play, I think). Then, of course, the music is absolutely brilliant! I'm always singing about "the cow as white as milk, the cape as red as blood, the hair as yellow as corn, the slipper as pure as gold".
Part of "Prologue/Into the Woods" (from the 2014 film)
3) Music Man
Other than Disney films, I think this was probably the first musical I was ever introduced to. (I'm talking about the 1962 movie version, but any version is great!)
It is about a conman who comes to the small town of River City, Iowa with the intent to convince them that he will organize their sons into a boys marching band with instruments and uniforms and himself as the leader. Then before he actually teaches them any music, he will skip town with the money.
I think the music is what I enjoy most about this play. It's just classic, old-fashioned music. None of this diaphragm singing and vocal riffs. They're cute little songs that are fun to sing along with. Then of course, the choreography is flat-out awesome!
The actors are all brilliant and perfect in their roles, but the real showstopper is Robert Preston as Professor Harold Hill (our conman). He has the perfect balance of charm, charisma, wit, and is smooth as silk. This show is a must see! "Ya got trouble, folks! Right here in River City!"
"Marian the Librarian"
2) Little Shop of Horrors
I have so much love for this musical!
It's about a man who works in a failing flower shop, but comes across a strange and unusual plant and suddenly becomes successful and famous because of it. However, he can only keep that fame if he continues to feed the plant which lives off a very peculiar substance… human blood!
It's such a messed up story, but by golly, it has THE catchiest music! It's a sort of 60's "doo-wop" style music which you would not expect to go with the story I just described. The writers could have totally gone in a different direction and made it a dark and serious story about a killer plant and the guy who goes out and kills people to feed it (and the guy's inner turmoil as he does so). There could have been a lot of dark and passionate songs, and it probably could have been great. However, they instead chose to give it more of an upbeat tone… And I really sort of enjoy it. It's still interesting to watch the main character begin to lose himself and torment himself as he does these horrible things, but it's done differently than you would normally see it done.
And in the movie, they change the ending to a much happier one, but you know what? I sort of prefer the original. I find it more poetic and frankly, it makes a little more sense.
And of course the music! I'm always humming these songs. "Feed me, Seymour. Feed me all night long."
"Prologue (Little Shop of Horrors)" (from 1989 film)
1) Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
Yes, yes, and YES! Best musical EVER!
It's the story of Joseph from the bible told in musical form. Starting from when he is sold by his brothers until he is made ruler over Egypt.
It's the music. It's all about the music! Every single song is catchy and flawless. The musical itself has pretty much no talking. It's just one song into another. There's basically every style of music included in this musical that you can think of (country, reggae, Charleston, Elvis, disco, etc.) and all of them are amazing! Never will I tire of them!
I've always loved the story of Joseph. It's so inspiring to watch him go from the lowest of lows to the highest of highs. Unfortunately, the musical cuts out any reference to God, but it is still inspiring to see him remain optimistic and persevere through his trials. Then add on fun characters, costumes, sets, and breath-taking musical numbers and you've got one heck of an entertaining musical.
(And of course if we're talking about the 1999 version, then Donny Osmond's voice is like chocolate to the ears). "Any dream will do."
"Joseph's Coat" (from the 1999 film)
***EDIT***
Bumping Singin' In the Rain out and pushing Into the Woods back into 5th place…
4) Legally Blonde the Musical
I've only recently discovered this which is why it's under "edit", but I have completely fallen in love with it!
Based on the movie, it's about sorority girl, Elle Woods, after she is dumped by her boyfriend to pursue a more "serious" career and relationship. She follows him to Harvard law school, sticking out like a sore, very pink thumb. As she fails to win back her boyfriend, she begins to discover that perhaps there is more to life than pursuing love and that she is capable of so much more than being just a pretty face.
I've always loved the movie with morals like "be true to yourself" and "girl power" and "you can be a girly girl and still get stuff done". Although there are a few changes, the musical sticks to the original story and spirit pretty well. I always said that Emmett needed a slightly bigger role in the movie… and in the musical, wouldn't you know they gave him one? I was very happy about that. The songs are super fun and catchy, I'm always finding myself humming one of them. There's some definite powerful vocals involved, then there's some fun dance ones, slow and powerful ones, workout-type ones, motivational ones, even some Irish dancing. The comedy is great, the story is interesting, the characters are fun, I love it all! "Omigosh! Omigosh, you guys! If there ever was a perfect couple, this one qualifies. Omigosh!"
"There! Right There! (Gay or European)"